Wrestlemania Card competition (New twist)

[the dark knight]

I DO know you've used too many matches, at least one which is pre WM19 and used a number of guys twice.


[Let me consult my spell checker....]



F.... A.... I.... L

rofl.
1) he edited it (like he always does) from 18 to 19.
2) i didnt read the part where it said you cant use the same superstar more than once
3) i just slammed my favorite matches frm manias post-18 really, didn't try to follow the "rules" of the thread.

PS: maybe im drunk but wasn't the title of the thread "wrestlemania dream card"? cuz if it is, then there's no need not to have the same guy wrestle twice >_>

Hey, Chavo vs kane was definately a massive match in the grand retrospect of things.

i loved it.

Ya, TDK failed big time. He also used almost everyone more than once. no:

yet you repped me for it :/

 

[MikeRaw]

rofl.
1) he edited it (like he always does) from 18 to 19.
2) i didnt read the part where it said you cant use the same superstar more than once
3) i just slammed my favorite matches frm manias post-18 really, didn't try to follow the "rules" of the thread.

PS: maybe im drunk but wasn't the title of the thread "wrestlemania dream card"? cuz if it is, then there's no need not to have the same guy wrestle twice >_>

So you're basically saying that you don't read the threads, and just go by the title? Not thta I'm surprised after seeing some of your posts as of late. But really, if you're going to respond, take a fucking hint and read the post, so you don't look like a complete moron.

yet you repped me for it :/

Rep still means something? Nah, in actuality, I repped you because I dfigured you're too fuckign stupid to figure out what you did wrong in the threadd so if you weren't repped (like I said in the first post, I'll rep anyone who does it, and triple rep the winner) you would call me a liar or soemthing of the sort if I didn't follow through.

 

[the dark knight]

So you're basically saying that you don't read the threads, and just go by the title? Not thta I'm surprised after seeing some of your posts as of late. But really, if you're going to respond, take a fucking hint and read the post, so you don't look like a complete moron.

no, im not you.

and cocksucker, quit editing your fucking posts. im sure my post wasn't that off before you edited it cuz i read a little and just posted my fav. matches from 18-25. didn't really care enough to add any details or do exactly what you want.


also, look at your own post, dumbass.

matches that happened from Wrestlemania 19 (2003) until 25 (now). So, you can't have Hogan vs Austin as your main event. It has to be a colelction of real matches from the past 7 wrestlemanias, put into their own card:
Example:
New Breed vs Originals (WM23)
Chris Benoit vs MVP (WM23)
The Rock vs Hulk Hogan (WM18)
Triple H vs John Cena (WM22)
Brock Lesnar vs Kurt Angle (WM19)

if you wanna edit your posts, edit them right.

Rep still means something? Nah, in actuality, I repped you because I dfigured you're too fuckign stupid to figure out what you did wrong in the threadd so if you weren't repped (like I said in the first post, I'll rep anyone who does it, and triple rep the winner) you would call me a liar or soemthing of the sort if I didn't follow through.

i didn't even read the part where you said you'll rep whoever does it tbh. and lol at "rep means nothing". yea sure.

if you insist ill follow the "rules" and post a card 2morrow. gotta sleep.

 

[MikeRaw]

no, im not you.

Lol, what? That made no sense. I read every thread before I post. Plus, why are you contradiction yourself. Later on in your post, you admit to not reading it all:

i didn't even read the part where you said you'll rep whoever does it tbh.

See?

and cocksucker, quit editing your fucking posts. im sure my post wasn't that off before you edited it cuz i read a little and just posted my fav. matches from 18-25.

No, your psot was off. The WM18 was the only thing I edited, changing it to 19. I also edited it long, long before you posted your card. Nice cop-out. Airfixx had no trouble seeing the rues, and he posted hours, if not a full day, before you. So, your editing story is lame. I edited long before you posted. Aside from that, you had far more problems. You didn't follow any of the rules that I posted, that were never edited, such as only have 8-12 matches, and not having guys used more than once.

didn't really care enough to add any details or do exactly what you want.

Then don't fucking post. Is it that hard? If you really don't want to take part in this, no one will care. No one asked you to post here, but if you're going to, at least do it right. It's not that hard. But this goes back to my whoel thign about you trying to be a heel. You just like to say shit like "I'm doing this my way, cause I don't give a damn how you want it", but all you're doing is make yourself look like an idiot. You don't look any cooler.

also, look at your own post, dumbass.
if you wanna edit your posts, edit them right.

If the only issue with your match card was that you put in matches from WM18, then you would have a great point. But, that was the least of your problems. The main problems were that you have way more than the set amount of matches, you used guys more than once, and you didn't label it at all. Again, I don't mind if you don't read my posts. But if you're going to respond to one, you should read it first.

i didn't even read the part where you said you'll rep whoever does it tbh.

Exactly. You didn't read the majority of the post.

lol at "rep means nothing". yea sure.

I was joking. See the "Nah, seriously...." next to it.

if you insist ill follow the "rules" and post a card 2morrow. gotta sleep.

I odn't insist you follow the rules. I'd rather you not post at all. But you can also feel free too, the more the better. Just if you do, don't intentionally fuck it up.

 

[Travis40]

1. Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero (WM 21)

2. MITB (WM 25)

3. Cruserweight Open (WM XX)

4. Christian vs. Chris Jericho (WM XX)

5. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. The Rock (WM XIX)

6. John Cena vs. Big Show (WM XX)

7. Randy Orton vs. Undertaker (WM 21)

8. Chris Benoit vs. Triple H vs. Shawn Michaels (WM XX)

9. Brock Lesnar vs. Kurt Angle (WM XIX)

 

[the dark knight]

Lol, what? That made no sense. I read every thread before I post. Plus, why are you contradiction yourself. Later on in your post, you admit to not reading it all:

yea it did. is it cleared off your memory? do you not remember the last time you and others read the title of a news thread, replied based on it without reading the actual report?

after you got owned you admitted you didn't read it. it wasn't the first and only time. a couple of weeks later someone made a joke about it in hiat and you were like "HEY! lol". if you're gonna act like none of this happened or that you cant remember it, fuck off and quit wasting my time.

so yea, the "im not you" was a lame joke. in other words, look who's talking.

lastly, i did not contradict myself. if you wanna play with words, try harder. you said i dont read threads before i replied. wrong. i DO read threads before i post, 99.999999% of them.

See?

nah man i dont. dont even know what i posted myself >_>

No, your psot was off. The WM18 was the only thing I edited, changing it to 19. I also edited it long, long before you posted your card. Nice cop-out. Airfixx had no trouble seeing the rues, and he posted hours, if not a full day, before you. So, your editing story is lame. I edited long before you posted. Aside from that, you had far more problems. You didn't follow any of the rules that I posted, that were never edited, such as only have 8-12 matches, and not having guys used more than once.

i clearly said my post was off. care to tell me anything that i dont already know? airfixx called me out on the 19-18 bit so my reason for that was that you edited your post. im pretty sure when i read the bits i read from your thread whether i was online that day or not, it was 18. other than that, no shit it was off. blow me.

Then don't fucking post. Is it that hard? If you really don't want to take part in this, no one will care. No one asked you to post here, but if you're going to, at least do it right. It's not that hard. But this goes back to my whoel thign about you trying to be a heel. You just like to say shit like "I'm doing this my way, cause I don't give a damn how you want it", but all you're doing is make yourself look like an idiot. You don't look any cooler.

why do you post? serious question.

and lol at bringing up the trying to be heel thing.

If the only issue with your match card was that you put in matches from WM18, then you would have a great point. But, that was the least of your problems. The main problems were that you have way more than the set amount of matches, you used guys more than once, and you didn't label it at all. Again, I don't mind if you don't read my posts. But if you're going to respond to one, you should read it first.

i already said you guys probably know which manias they were from. i was too lazy to edit again and add details or organize. simple as that.

Exactly. You didn't read the majority of the post.

oh really?

I was joking. See the "Nah, seriously...." next to it.

okay..

I odn't insist you follow the rules. I'd rather you not post at all. But you can also feel free too, the more the better. Just if you do, don't intentionally fuck it up.

lololol. intentionally fuck it up?



edit-

all done on msn.

 

[Next Big Thing]

Next Big Thing:
Following of Guidelines- 8.5/10
You followed the guidelines nicely. Noone appeared more than once, you had 9 matches, and 3 stipulation matches. You also had the maximum of title matches. The biggest one, with having at least 5 of the 7 Mania’s represented, was also followed. Props to you.

UnderRatedRSuperstar​

Following of Guidlines- 10/10
You organised nice, which was a nice bonus, so thanks. You followed most of the rules as well. No one appeared multiple times, there were only 3 specialty matches, and only 3 title matches, so good job. You also used at least 5 different Mania’s.

Two things. First, how did I only get 8.5/10 for this and he got 10/10? I followed every rule, so I'm a bit confused about this one. Second, he used Christian twice. He used the MITB from WM25 and Christian was one of the participants, and then he used Jericho vs. Christian. And I realize this is just a fun competition, but I like to be a dick from time to time.

 

[MikeRaw]

Shit, and no, you're not being a dick, that's a very valid point. Sorry about that. Gimme a minute, I'll straighten it out. He never listed who was in the MITB, and I completely forgot Christian. Like I said, just gimme a minute. Completely my bad.

 

[MikeRaw]

UPDATED Scores:

Next Big Thing:
1. (MITB) CM Punk vs. Kane. Vs. Mark Henry vs. Finlay vs. Kofi Kingston vs. Christian vs. Shelton Benjamin vs. MVP - WM25
Decent. But it was probably the 3rd best MITB. Every Wrestlemania needs one, but personally, I wouldn't have chosen this.
2. (U.S. Championship) JBL vs. Chris Benoit - WM22
Very, very nice choice. It's probably one of the best choices for a 2nd match on the card. It's got a title on the line, so it means something, and it's got two contrasting ring styles, who can still work well together.
3. The Undertaker vs. Randy Orton - WM21
Third on the card? Interesting. After two pretty big matches before this one, I would've put in a lesser match, like say the women's championship, to break it up. This was a pretty important match. Nonetheless, it's a classic matchup, and was one of the better Mania matches from WM21.
4. Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho - WM19
Now this is a great choice. In fact, I'm surprised more people didn't choose this one. One of my favourite matches.
5. (Women’s Championship) Trish Stratus vs. Mickie James - WM22
Like I said, for me, I would've put this one a little further down, but then again, it works here as well to give a slight break in the marquee matches before the next 3. Probably the best choice for a Diva match of all the ones you could've chose. Nice choice.
6. (Hardcore Match) Edge vs. Mick Foley - WM22
Beautiful.
7. (World Heavyweight Championship) Kurt Angle vs. Eddie Guerrero - WM20
Perfect choice. It just fits this WM that you created perfectly. You've basically had a bit of every type of wrestler, now that you've included these two. Not to mention, it's a great match. They both went for 20 minutes, and I'd say both styles complimented eachother nicely. There's a problem though... I was really diggin' this, until I noticed one thing. You lose some points on realism. This match was a WWE championship in real life, and on top of that, you have anothe WWE Championship later on in the show. That'll take some "realism" points away...
8. (No DQ match) The Big Show vs. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - WM24
I really don't think this one was needed. You already had two "gimmick" matches, and maybe it's just me, but I wasn't feeling this one at all when it happened. I'm not a fan of either guy, really.
9. (WWE Championship) Triple H vs. John Cena - WM22
Nice.

Following of Guidelines- 8.5/10
You followed the guidelines nicely. Noone appeared more than once, you had 9 matches, and 3 stipulation matches. You also had the maximum of title matches. The biggest one, with having at least 5 of the 7 Mania’s represented, was also followed. Props to you.
Realism- 8/10
Pretty solid. I mean, I could definitely see this being a WM card, except for the fact that you had Eddit vs Kurt listed as WHC, when it's actually a WWE championship match, thus giving you two WWE title matches...
Balance- 6.5/10
The balance was a bit off for me. I would’ve had a big match like Taker/Orton take place later, and maybe had the divas match earlier. Probably would’ve opened up with JBL/Benoit too.
Match Quality- 8.5/10
I gave my thoughts under each match…
Total- 31.5/40

RKO Legacy
1. Trish Stratus vs. Victoria
Hmmm.... A women's match to open the show? I understand it being low in the card, but I'd say you wanna start off with something else before that, perphaps Matt/Jeff, or even Rey/Eddie...
2. Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero
Solid second match.
3. MITB from WrestleMania 24
Very good choice of MITB. This was one of the better ones. Probably 2nd best. All good participants. Overall, just a nice choice.
4. Matt Hardy vs. Jeff Hardy
I would've opened the show with this. I think it would've been perfect there, to start off the show with a bang, but not too much of a bang that you can't live up to it after... However, just having it on the card is a good choice. This was Extreme Rules from WM25, right?
5. Undertaker vs. Edge
Solid match. I probably would've had it after Angle/Michaels though.
6. Kurt Angle vs. Shawn Michaels
Awesome match. One of my favourites.
7. The Rock vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin
See above.
8. John Cena vs. Triple H
Pretty solid choice. Next Big Thing had the same one, but for all I know, you could've written it at the same time, and there's no point deductions for having a match or two the same. It fits in nicely with your card though. This was a hell of a match, and a good choice as the WWE title match, although to change it up a bit from Next Big Thing, I may have put it earlier in the card, and maybe had Edge/Taker last...

Following of Guidelines- 7.5/10
Pretty good. No one appeared more than once. You had matches from at least 5 Mania’s, and you had two stipulation matches… Good job on that... But, It would've helped if you listed what WM's some of the matches were from, along with the type of match, or title involved. For example, Rock vs Austin... That happened 3 times. Which one was it? That's a key detail to knowing if there was a title involved or not, and how good the match was. Although, I take it it was a non-title one (2003), seein as you have Taker/Edge and Cena/Triple H on the card as well.
Realism- 9/10
Solid.
Balance- 8/10
Decent. I wouldn’t open up any PPV with a Diva’s match though. Aside from that, it was pretty well balanced. I like the way you arranged the final four.
Match Quality- 8/10
Thoughts under each match…
Total- 32.5/40

UnderRatedRSuperstar​

1.MITB - WM 25
Wasn't much of a fan of this one myself. I am a fan of MITB starting out the show though.
2.Womens Championship Trish Stratus(c) Vs Mickie James - WM 22
Second on the card is a good spot for this.
3.Christian Vs Chris Jericho w/ Trish Stratus - WM XX
I really like this. Im surprised no one else used this yet. A very good mid-card match.
4.Playboy EGM Sable & Torrie Wilson Vs Stacy Keibler & Miss Jackie - WM XX
Nice, bro. It's a good little segment/match to break up the night, and of course, there's nothing like hot divas.
5.Big Show Vs Floyd "Money" Mayweather - WM XXIVNot a fan of this at all, but if it has to be on here, this is the right spot in the card for it.
6.Shawn Michaels Vs Undertaker - WM 25
Well, the match is good. It's obviously a classic, even though it just happened. I would've tried soemthing different though, such as putting it as the final match on, or something like that, to mix it up a bit.
7.WWE CHAMPIONSHIP Brock Lesner(c) Vs Kurt Angle - WM XIX
Love it. Two of my favourite past superstars. It had a few botches in the match, but they didn't really ruin it. Pretty good build to this match too. Nice choice.
8.WORLD HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP Triple h(c) Vs Batista - WM 21
Yup, solid choice.

Following of Guidlines- 7.5/10
You organised nice, which was a nice bonus, so thanks. You followed most of the rules as well. There were only 3 specialty matches, and only 3 title matches, so good job. You also used at least 5 different Mania’s. But, ,unfortuanetly, you violated the "only one appearance per person" rule.
Realism- 7.5/10
Match wise, it's the most realistic yet. But you used Christian twice, which is a key loss
Balance- 9.5/10
A near perfect balance. The matches weren’t as good as the other cards, but the balance was the best yet.
Quality of Matches- 7.5/10
Total- 32/40

Airfixx:
Eddie G vs Rey (WM21)
Perfect opener. I was hoping someone would open the show with this.
Kofi v Kane v Shelton v Christian v Punk v Henry v MVP v Finlay (WM25) - MITB LADDER MATCH
Alot of people must like this match.
Benoit v JBL (WM22) - US TITLE
Like I said to Next Big Thing, I really like this choice. It's just a good, old fashioned match, that mixes two different styles. It also just seems to be what the US Title should be about.
Taker vs Orton (WM21)
Good match, good spot. The card seems like it'll be getting a little top-heavy though. We'll see what happens...
Rock v Austin (WM19)
Woah, woah, seriously? This low on the card? To mix it up, I probably would've chosen the WM17 one, where Austin turns...
Edge vs Foley (WM22) - HARDCORE MATCH
Surprised this hasn't been used. Awesome fucking match.
Hogan v Vince (WM19) - "WHO MADE WRESTLEMANIA???" STREETFIGHTWow... Surprised this is the first I've seen of it, so far. This was actually a cool match. Ringwork wise, it won't go down as an all time great, but they made it work, and it's in a good spot on the card here.
Brock vs Angle (WM19) - WORLD HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP
Hmm... I smell a screw up, lol. This match was actually for the WWE Championship... Even if you change it to say that, it'd still be screwed, as you can't have the same title defended twice... You were going so well, too:n:
HBK v Flair (WM24) - IF FLAIR LOSES HE RETIRES
:clapping:
Cena V HHH (WM22) - WWE CHAMPIONSHIP
This was indeed a classic. I'm getting a bit sick of reviewint it, but that's not really your fault. It's just that everyone uses it. It's a good match, and if I were to ignore the flaw in your previous title match (Lesnar/Angle) it would top off a near-perfect card. Of course, the Angle/Lesnar mistake fucked it up for you though.


Following of Guidelines- 8/10
Almost perfect. You followed all the rules, except that you have the same title defended twice. That's more of a "realism" flaw though.
Realism- 6.5/10
A bit too stacked for my liking. Maybe one less “big time” match would’ve made it more realistic… The main prolem though was the Lesnar/Angle match. You had it listed as a WHC match, but it was for the WWE title. In that case, you had two WWE title matches...
Balance- 7/10
It started off with great balance. Afterwards, it was a nice design of the card, but again, just one too many big matches.
Match Quality- 9/10
Total- 30.5/40


The Dark Knight
rock vs hogan
jericho vs triple h
austin vs scott hall (just for the finish lol)
austin vs rock
lesnar vs angle
vince vs hogan
taker vs kane
angle vs hbk
taker vs orton
hbk vs vince
foley vs edge
trish vs mickie (for the pussy rub...it still gives me boners)
kane vs chavo guerrero
hbk vs flair

Following of guidelines- 2/10
1.5 is basically for even writing down matches, and for sing different Wrestlemania’s… But you used way more than the maximum 12 matches, you used wrestlers more than once, you used too many title matches, and you didn’t label anything. The reason I gave you a 2 is because one mistake I’ll give you the beneifit of. I originally said you can use WM18-25, and changed it to 19-25. I still think it’s a bullshit excuse, seeing as I edited it long before you viewed this thread, but whatever. I’ll give you the benefit of doubt on that one. It doesn’t matter though, cause you missed all the other rules that were set it stone anyway.
Balance- 1/10
There’s not even an order there. As you said, you just threw them all down, in no order, so… Yeah. The 1 is for including a women’s match.
Realism- 0/10
I don’t think I really need an explanation
Match Quality- 6/10
You chose some nice matches
Total- 9/40


Travis40:
Rey Mysterio vs Eddie Guerrero
Can’t go wrong here. Two highly skilled guys, a good match, and fit perfectly for the opening match.
Money In The Bank Ladder Match (WM25):
BOOOOOOO. Everyone has chosen this one, and it was one of the lesser MITB’s IMO.
Cruiserweight Open Challenge:
Hey, that’s actually pretty cool. Nice way to have a little comedy/fun, as well as a decent match. It’s also one that hasn’t bee used yet. Pretty cool.
Christian vs Chris Jericho
Perfect spot for this match
Stone Cold Steve Austin vs The Rock
I like putting it in the middle of the card, instead of the very top, but I would’ve put it up maybe one more spot. I’d have swapped it with Cena/Show, cause remember, Cena wasn’t as big at the time. It was also a smart move to have it be the WM19 one, as it wasn’t for the title.
US Title: John Cena vs Big Show
Nice way to get both guys involved, and I don’t believe this one has been used yet.
Randy Orton vs The Undertaker
For some reason, it blends pretty nicely with your card. It gives it another dynamic, and what would Wrestlemania be without Taker?
World Heavyweight Championship: Chris Benoit vs Triple H vs Shawn Michaels
A rare choice. But a nice one.
WWE Championship: Brock Lesnar vs Kurt Angle
Been used quite a bit, so it’s not as great a choice as previously. I probably would’ve chosen like Angle vs Eddie, just to mix it up, maybe even Cena vs HBK (if you didn’t use Cena earlier) but still, you can never go wrong with this two.

Following of Guidelines- 7.5/10
So close to being perfect... You used Christian twice...
Realism- 7.5/10
Same as above...
Balance- 8/10
Pretty nice. Again though, I would've added a Divas match, and flipped the Cena/Show match with Austin/Rock... Other than that, it flowed really nice.
Match Quality- 8/10
Total- 31/40

 

[MikeRaw]

Updated Results:
6th place goes to The Dark Knight with a score of 9/40
5th place goes to Airfixx with a score of 30.5/40
4th place goes to Travis40 with a score of 31/40
3rd place goes to Next Big Thing with a score of 31.5/40
2nd place goes to UnderRatedRSuperstar with a score of 32/40
1st place goes to RKO Legacy with a score of 32.5

 

[Luke Flywalker]

Sweet deal. I thought something was fishy about that. BTW, my apologies for not labeling the matches, I didn't realize labels were going to be required (wasn't specified aywhere). I realized you did it in your examples after I'd posted and didn't want to edit to make it seem like I added a different match seeing as I posted at the same time as NBT.

And yes, Austin vs. Rock from '03. I didn't use any title matches twice.

 

[MikeRaw]

Sweet deal. I thought something was fishy about that. BTW, my apologies for not labeling the matches, I didn't realize labels were going to be required (wasn't specified aywhere). I realized you did it in your examples after I'd posted and didn't want to edit to make it seem like I added a different match seeing as I posted at the same time as NBT.

And yes, Austin vs. Rock from '03. I didn't use any title matches twice.

Ya, TBH, I was a little distracted while reviewing the first time. I was spot on for most of it, but I rushed a little at a part or two, and as a result, posted before I fully checked over. The results I posted this time I checked over, and they're final.. Too bad there's a tie between you and Next Big Thing though. I was trying to think of a way to have a tie-breaker, but it'd really go further than it needs to, lol. Not to mention, both were deserving of the win.
Congrats to both of you though.

 

[Airfixx]

@ Mike.... FEEDBACK FEEDBACK (lol)....

"The card seems like it'll be getting a little top-heavy though."

What exactly do you mean by this? The cards are innevitably gonna be star-heavy, but the profile/stature of the matches gradually increases throughout the event until you get to THEE MEvent. As long as you've got a strong undercard then I don't understand how a card CAN be considered "top heavy"... Surely that's the intention (give or take maybe a squash or a 'give the crowd a breather' match during the second half of the show).


I'd have ended up with 3 world champ matches had I used Rock/Austin WM17.... Besides, I like the WM19 match much better... Rocky wearing Austin's wastecoat and acting like him as he lays the smackdown - Rock at his best, in-ring wise.

re: Kurt/Brock... I really couldn't remember. Should have checked rather than 'using the force'.


As for MITB@WM25 being used so much, I just think the others take key stars away from bigger/better matches... Whether it be Edge, Benoit or whoever... Most of the guys in this years MITB have yet to go onto bigger and better things.

Again.... Nice comp.... Good Man!!

Gonna have another crack just for fun.


p.s. NBThing fucked up and used the WWE title twice just like I did. (Eddie v Kurt was a WWE title match)... I reckon that must give us a clear winner, no?

 

[MikeRaw]

Absolutely.
Tony Chimel: Ladies and Gentleman, your winner... RKO Legacy!

 

[MikeRaw]

Updated Results:
6th place goes to The Dark Knight with a score of 9/40
5th place goes to Airfixx with a score of 30.5/40
4th place goes to Travis40 with a score of 31/40
3rd place goes to Next Big Thing with a score of 31.5/40
2nd place goes to UnderRatedRSuperstar with a score of 32/40
1st place goes to RKO Legacy with a score of 32.5

Any more problems, PM me. I'm gonna close this now.