Wrestlemania Card competition (New twist)

[MikeRaw]

I thought this would be a cool idea.. I know we've had multiple "Make your dream Wrestlemania card" threads, which were pretty good, but making another right now, exactly the same, would be dumb. So I put a bit of a spin on it. Here's what we'll do. We'll each make a Dream Wrestlemania card, but instead of being able to use any superstars, and any matches, and basically be as random as you want, there's a rule you have to go by. Instead, you have to use real matches that happened from Wrestlemania 19 (2003) until 25 (now). So, you can't have Hogan vs Austin as your main event. It has to be a colelction of real matches from the past 7 wrestlemanias, put into their own card:
Example:
New Breed vs Originals (WM23)
Chris Benoit vs MVP (WM23)
The Rock vs Hulk Hogan (WM18)
Triple H vs John Cena (WM22)
Brock Lesnar vs Kurt Angle (WM19)

Get it? Hope so.
So, I encourage you guys not to be pansies, and actually try to make up as good of a card as you can. I'll rate them as they come, and at the end, choose the best one, and while everyone who makes one gets rep, the winner gets triple rep. It'll be rated on: Realism, following of guidlines, and of course, the quality of the card
Few rules:
1-Has to be realistic. So you can't have too many main eventers. It has to be balanced.
2-Must have matches from at least 5 of the 7 selected Wrestlemania's
3-A wrestler can only appear once on the card
4-Use at least 2 stipulation matches, but no more than 4
5-No more than 4 title matches
6-At least 8 matches on the card, no more than 12

 

[Next Big Thing]

1. (MITB) CM Punk vs. Kane. Vs. Mark Henry vs. Finlay vs. Kofi Kingston vs. Christian vs. Shelton Benjamin vs. MVP - WM25

2. (U.S. Championship) JBL vs. Chris Benoit - WM22

3. The Undertaker vs. Randy Orton - WM21

4. Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho - WM19

5. (Women’s Championship) Trish Stratus vs. Mickie James - WM22

6. (Hardcore Match) Edge vs. Mick Foley - WM22

7. (World Heavyweight Championship) Kurt Angle vs. Eddie Guerrero - WM20

8. (No DQ match) The Big Show vs. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - WM24

9. (WWE Championship) Triple H vs. John Cena - WM22

 

[Luke Flywalker]

Dark Match: Unified Tag Titles
1. Trish Stratus vs. Victoria
2. Rey Mysterio vs. Eddie Guerrero
3. MITB from WrestleMania 24
4. Matt Hardy vs. Jeff Hardy
5. Undertaker vs. Edge
6. Kurt Angle vs. Shawn Michaels
7. The Rock vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin
8. John Cena vs. Triple H

 

[Klide]

1.MITB - WM 25
2.Womens Championship Trish Stratus(c) Vs Mickie James - WM 22
3.Christian Vs Chris Jericho w/ Trish Stratus - WM XX
4.Playboy EGM Sable & Torrie Wilson Vs Stacy Keibler & Miss Jackie - WM XX
5.Big Show Vs Floyd "Money" Mayweather - WM XXIV
6.Shawn Michaels Vs Undertaker - WM 25
7.WWE CHAMPIONSHIP Brock Lesner(c) Vs Kurt Angle - WM XIX
8.WORLD HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP Triple h(c) Vs Batista - WM 21

 

[Airfixx]

Your game Mike, fair play, but why discount WM 1 > 18?


Cena V HHH (WM22) - WWE CHAMPIONSHIP
HBK v Flair (WM24) - IF FLAIR LOSES HE RETIRES
Brock vs Angle (WM19) - WORLD HEAVYWEIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP
Hogan v Vince (WM19) - "WHO MADE WRESTLEMANIA???" STREETFIGHT
Edge vs Foley (WM22) - HARDCORE MATCH
Rock v Austin (WM19)
Taker vs Orton (WM21)
Benoit v JBL (WM22) - US TITLE
Kofi v Kane v Shelton v Christian v Punk v Henry v MVP v Finlay (WM25) - MITB LADDER MATCH
Eddie G vs Rey (WM21)

 

[MikeRaw]

Because it'd be too large of a choice.. I originally had it like that, but I figured it would end up too close to what Montana did in the past, and if you look back over time, in the WM's, there's so many great matches. It would make for great choices, but for some reason, I have a feeling half the posters on this site wouldn't end up doing it, as they wouldn't have the effort to go back in time and look at some old matches. Of course some would, guys like you, and probably CMS, or noumenon, etc, but the majority of guys can't be bothered to think too far back, lol. Not to mention, limiting i actually makes it a little harder for people. Not as many matches to choose from, so it's interesting to see what they come up with to try to set themselves apart from the other people, while choosing from the same 70 or so matches.
Anyway, I'll start reviewing some of them once we get a few more in. Maybe 2 or3 more..

 

[LKP]

Kofi v Kane v Shelton v Christian v Punk v Henry v MVP v Finlay (WM25)
Eddie g Vs Rey 619 (WM21)
Kurt Angle vs Brock lesnar (WM19)
Edge vs Foley (WM22)
Rock Vs Austin (WM19)
HHH Vs Batista
Christian vs Jericho (WM20)
Taker vs Hbk(WM25)

 

[Airfixx]

Because it'd be too large of a choice.. I originally had it like that, but I figured it would end up too close to what Montana did in the past, and if you look back over time, in the WM's, there's so many great matches. It would make for great choices, but for some reason, I have a feeling half the posters on this site wouldn't end up doing it, as they wouldn't have the effort to go back in time and look at some old matches. Of course some would, guys like you, and probably CMS, or noumenon, etc, but the majority of guys can't be bothered to think too far back, lol.

I say bollocks to the lack of effort of others... Let it be their undoing (not their saviour)! ;o]

 

[Luke Flywalker]

^It's too easy to avoid repetitive names if you do all the WrestleManias... not to mention too many epic matches that everyone would select, you'd have a lot of identical cards, I believe.

Granted you'd only be able to choose one main event with the WWE Championship, that would be a challenging decision... but all in all, most people's cards would definitely be too alike.

 

[newmie]

The New Breed: Elijah Burke, Marcus Cor Von, Matt Striker and Kevin Thorn vs. the ECW Originals: Rob Van Dam, Sabu, The Sandman and Tommy Dreamer - WM 23

Team Angle (Benjamin and Haas) vs. Los Guerrero's (Chavo and Eddie) vs. Rhyno and Chris Benoit - WWE Tag Team Championships! WM 19

Christian vs. Chris Jericho - WM 20

Hulk Hogan vs. Mr. McMahon - Street Fight! WM 19

Mick Foley vs. Edge - Hardcore Match! WM 22

Rey Mysterio vs. Randy Orton vs. Kurt Angle - World Heavyweight Championship! WM 22

The Rock vs. Steve Austin - WM 19

John Cena vs. Triple H - WWE Championship! WM 23

The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels - WM 24

 

[the dark knight]

sigh, keep forgetting which WMs were they. thank god for wiki..

rock vs hogan
jericho vs triple h
austin vs scott hall (just for the finish lol)
austin vs rock
lesnar vs angle
vince vs hogan
taker vs kane
angle vs hbk
taker vs orton
hbk vs vince
foley vs edge
trish vs mickie (for the pussy rub...it still gives me boners)
kane vs chavo guerrero
hbk vs flair

edit

fuck i forgot to mention which manias they're from. oh well, you probably know.

 

[MikeRaw]

I've started to review a few of them. I've got most done, but I can't post yet, and give away the results... It's Tuesday now, I'll leave it open until Thursday, and POSSIBLY Friday...

 

[Airfixx]

sigh, keep forgetting which WMs were they. thank god for wiki..

rock vs hogan
jericho vs triple h
austin vs scott hall (just for the finish lol)
austin vs rock
lesnar vs angle
vince vs hogan
taker vs kane
angle vs hbk
taker vs orton
hbk vs vince
foley vs edge
trish vs mickie (for the pussy rub...it still gives me boners)
kane vs chavo guerrero
hbk vs flair

edit

fuck i forgot to mention which manias they're from. oh well, you probably know.

I DO know you've used too many matches, at least one which is pre WM19 and used a number of guys twice.


[Let me consult my spell checker....]



F.... A.... I.... L

 

[MikeRaw]

Ya, TDK failed big time. He also used almost everyone more than once. no:

 

[Kizza]

Hey, Chavo vs kane was definately a massive match in the grand retrospect of things.