Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Just Juice]

Having the plugged just pulled on his first time game - is 100% going to have repercussions on confidence to running any future games. You don't shit on someone - for making mistakes at first time of asking.

 

[Poyser]

Not going to lie - but its fucking shitty to do to a first time host.

I’m not trying to bitch out blaine here, there was just no point in putting numerous days more of effort into a game that wasn’t winnable from here

 

[Rugrat]

Its also not blaine fault. The game should have been looked over by one of us. So ots really out (moddimg teams ) fault in the end

It is his fault, it’s on him to seek a co-host. Just don’t think there’s any need to dig him out on it really, he did his best and it’s not like he tried to make a wonky game.

 

[Rugrat]

So uh... we’re counting this one in the records right?

 

[Poyser]

We should probably make it a rule that all hosts must have somebody more experienced check their setups unless the host has hosted >5 games that weren’t considered to be bad

 

[Comrade Khan]

So uh... we’re counting this one in the records right?

Up to you guys. I personally would not but if town wants the win I won't oppose

 

[Dirk Dickbutt]

I had Smark and Haza look over and help my game. If it's anyone fault, it's mine for the set up. Like I said, will never happen again

 

[Ace]

And giving deadqts to ppl who can be revived. Unfortunately this breaks the game

All I know is I wasn't in the deadqt but can't speak for others.

Except we were gonna lynch kajuh based on him not being your Mason lol.....

Yes but that's just you disliking a reviver role, it's got nothing to do with the problem of being able to revive a janitored target, just your problem with revivers in general. Which may be valid but that's a personal preference thing.

Same with the PGO. You really shouldn't assume these things from a new host and I have certainly heard of PGO's being unlimited shots - they can still be lynched.

Anyway to suggest you couldn't have still won is silly to me, I had no cop shots since I was VT and while I had you as a scum read, you may well have been able to convince town as a whole otherwise.

I understand you may be frustrated if there were botches/imbalances but this all feels a bit harsh to just executively decide to end the game of a new host because you don't feel like fighting to the end.

 

[Comrade Khan]

It is his fault, it’s on him to seek a co-host. Just don’t think there’s any need to dig him out on it really, he did his best and it’s not like he tried to make a wonky game.

Nah its our responsibility as a mod team to ensure new hosts are helped proper too n the game is looked over. We defo have to take our share of the blame here imo

 

[Comrade Khan]

All I know is I wasn't in the deadqt but can't speak for others.


Yes but that's just you disliking a reviver role, it's got nothing to do with the problem of being able to revive a janitored target, just your problem with revivers in general. Which may be valid but that's a personal preference thing.

Same with the PGO. You really shouldn't assume these things from a new host and I have certainly heard of PGO's being unlimited shots - they can still be lynched.

Anyway to suggest you couldn't have still won is silly to me, I had no cop shots since I was VT and while I had you as a scum read, you may well have been able to convince town as a whole otherwise.

I understand you may be frustrated if there were botches/imbalances but this all feels a bit harsh to just executively decide to end the game of a new host because you don't feel like fighting to the end.

Revivers and janitors can never ever exist together. Period

 

[Comrade Khan]

Like I love you ace, but the game was 100% broken lel

 

[Just Juice]

I mean they can - just you dont have a Death Chat. But they can exist in the same game.

 

[RDK]

Lock it up imo.

Thanks for hosting Blaine and sorry about the finale

 

[Rugrat]

I had Smark and Haza look over and help my game. If it's anyone fault, it's mine for the set up. Like I said, will never happen again

Nah its our responsibility as a mod team to ensure new hosts are helped proper too n the game is looked over. We defo have to take our share of the blame here imo

I’d put the blame on Smark and Haza in this case tbh

 

[Laughable Chimp]

They’re pretty much always 1 shot lol. I’ve seen unlimited before but it’s bad and is usually bitched about

Doddsy killed 2/3 scum being an unlim PGO once lol, yeah it’s bad

If this was town of salem mafia, he wasn't unlimited he was 3 shot.