Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Odo]

1. Nope

2. Yup

3. They’re mostly ok, however I do have a question for him, but I don’t want to give him chance to prepare an answer so I’m slow playing it for now until he reappears

How do you see EV right now?

 

[Odo]

FTR I am also fairly certain Phenom is town

 

[Comrade Khan]

1. Nope

2. Yup

3. They’re mostly ok, however I do have a question for him, but I don’t want to give him chance to prepare an answer so I’m slow playing it for now until he reappears

How do you see EV right now?

I like E-V so far. I like that he questioned Tweet once Tweet's points were bad, and he was quick to jump on inconsistencies. I obviously don't love that his vote is still on me, but the way he's going about things, and focusing on certain things (again, like tweet's inconsitent statements) appears to be the town EV I'm used to. What about you?

(editted cuz i had no actual reason to tag him)

 

[Odo]

I didn’t like his entrance much, and if Tweet flipped scum, I’d have some questions.

Their interaction kinda reads to me like how I’d expect 2 scum players that went rogue and into business for themselves to look

Of course, the actual chance of that is low

Also, claiming characters is universally a bad move in Smark games (I certainly won’t be claiming mine) so I’m inclined to not look on anyone demanding characters favourably. We shouldn’t be talking about characters at all

 

[Odo]

^ I'd like that answered and I'm getting very sceptical of your responses to the questions. First you try to play it all off as a joke and don't answer my question then when Jeff pushes, it becomes an outed hider is bad for town (not disputing that it is a bad thing). There's inconsistencies forming.

Also, I have iterated my stance on Jeff & Barry a couple of times already, so trying to suggest I'm pushing for a Barry lynch is when I've said I want to see more from Barry.

Also responding to questions with questions with implied statements isn't an ideal look, similar to what you did to Jeff here. It's probably you on the defence but it doesn't scream a townie justifying his points as opposed to trying to misdirect conversation.

Like this is a great example of what I mean. The bolded looks like distancing to me, theres no bite and no commitment. He even provides Tweet with a plausible defence, why????

Evans, walk me through your rationale here pls

 

[Comrade Khan]

Well that certainly wasn't the answer I was expecting for you but interesting none the less. These are things I obviously did not take into consideration, perhaps due being at odds with Tweet myself, so EV calling him out would naturally appease me.

You're not wrong actually regarding claiming characters or claiming in general. Asking for more flavour, in the end, is probably not super useful. We all how smark rolls, and there's an extremely high chance that scum are going to have full fakes. Has he even had a game with no full fakes? I don't think I've seen one in my career

 

[Lethal]

Jeff, you and Tweets had gone into a slumber which negated 90% of my focus so far in the game. I'm not going to talk to myself or try and generate stuff with people not around

 

[Lethal]

Is that a rabbit ears moment?

 

[Odo]

Jeff, you and Tweets had gone into a slumber which negated 90% of my focus so far in the game. I'm not going to talk to myself or try and generate stuff with people not around

I had a harsh answer to this but then I remembered its the era so instead I'll give some advice and say you should ALWAYS be trying to generate some stuff, regardless of how active the game is.

Your thoughts on Barry, Tweet and Evans please

 

[Comrade Khan]

Jeff, you and Tweets had gone into a slumber which negated 90% of my focus so far in the game. I'm not going to talk to myself or try and generate stuff with people not around

Yeah that's fairly accurate at least. It most definitely dominated the thread last night, so if you had nothing to add there, I suppose I can accept that for now.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Is that a rabbit ears moment?

what is?

 

[Comrade Khan]

and actually, didn't you disappear after needlessly saying you were essentially more than just a 2x voter?

 

[Comrade Khan]

oh nvm lethal i think i missed ur 1 am-ish claiming

 

[Odo]

I'll character claim, but I;m not fully claiming.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Sorry pal, missus was screaming at me to get in the car.

I'm R2-D2 and C3PO



You getting this emotional suggests to me you're town, which could lead credence to Jeff being scum as I doubt that this exchange between Tweets and Jeff is anything cohesive.



Your lack of is disturbing

This though. Why does Tweet being emotional leads you to think he's town, when last two times he got emo he was scum and indy ,respectively.