Knights of the Old Republic Mafia - Game Thread

[Ace]

Not gonna lie, even though I suss Tweet I'm uncomfortable at how easily this lynch is just cruising along without much contest.
Maybe it's just paranoia but I don't like it when there is such an uncontested lynch on d1.

 

[NotBrutus]

How many scum bois have we caught already

 

[Alco]

Yeah well that whimsical answer kinda doesn't sit well with me tbh.
Occams Razor = the simplest answer is most likely the right one.

Why is it whimsical? I can't have gut reactions to things?
I need you to clarify this. Why are you only picking apart this specific reaction I had to Doddsy?

 

[NotBrutus]

I like Alco’s vibe rn tbh

That's not what I'm implying at all.

I'm saying a scum PR barely ever exists, and if you're going to fake a PR, you're unlikely to do it with a CHARACTER that is not fairly obviously a town character.
IE, Occams Razor implies Doddsy's PR is indeed town and you doing your whole 'for some reason' thing just feels like filler.

Also, don’t see Doddy coming up with a fake PR that quickly, unless he already thought of it beforehand, which lol

 

[Poyser]

Not gonna lie, even though I suss Tweet I'm uncomfortable at how easily this lynch is just cruising along without much contest.
Maybe it's just paranoia but I don't like it when there is such an uncontested lynch on d1.

Why? What would you expect a hypothetical scum team to be doing here if tweet is scum?

 

[Alco]

For me I don’t really understand why he would express caution just like I said at the time lol. So he wants to be voted, and? I even asked him what possible role would mean we have to be cautious and he had nothing so it’s not even like he had something in mind lol, which means it’s probably just virtue signalling, kinda like how for some reason scum keep telling us to watch for the executioner and thinking that’s a good tactic

Yea okay your point about virtue signalling is not bad.

The way he presented it, it looked like he thought "dude your posting is shite and only now you're adding the roles shenanigans to it after CP and Poyser tag on", which is pretty much what I was thinking as I was reading through it.

 

[Alco]

Now Ace is commenting on the wagon speed as well. He might be in cahoots with Smark and Jeff

 

[Lethal]

Alright well that's 3 posts where lethal hasn't said anything completed r word so he's probably town

Am I really that easy?

I'm also uneasy on Smark. But I was uneasy on him last game re: Blaine and he was town so

 

[Poyser]

Nah Im kinda kidding, I know you can at least make a good couple of posts before you fold as scum

I have good vibes from the first couple though, I feel like you are probably town

 

[Ace]

Why is it whimsical? I can't have gut reactions to things?
I need you to clarify this. Why are you only picking apart this specific reaction I had to Doddsy?

You're welcome to have gut reactions to things. I just think your 'gut reactions' seem made up.

Why? What would you expect a hypothetical scum team to be doing here if tweet is scum?

Yeah fair point actually. As I said - paranoia.

 

[Ace]

I guess I see d1 as a place where we usually end up with a bunch of prods and pokes at various players and it inevitably ends up with us having to rush a lynch, so when everyone seems so settled on a single lynch it feels too good to be true.

 

[Ace]

Now Ace is commenting on the wagon speed as well. He might be in cahoots with Smark and Jeff

Why would that put me in cahoots with Smark and Jeff? I don't recall them questioning it?

 

[Poyser]

I guess I see d1 as a place where we usually end up with a bunch of prods and pokes at various players and it inevitably ends up with us having to rush a lynch, so when everyone seems so settled on a single lynch it feels too good to be true.

Ya I get why people get uncomfortable at a fast wagon but I don't think its usually very indicative of much and there's far too many variables to factor it in. Like even if they're town, that's not usually why the wagon is moving so fast because if someone from town is being wagoned heftily a lot of the time scum won't even feel the need to get on and there'll be some good guying etc

And if they're scum its like well they might have teammates that aren't really capeable of swaying, they might think their teammate is completely fucked so trying to look good off him

Most of the time the soft defence of a teammate is simply just trying to start another wagon, which is another reason why big man's wagon on haza is interesting to me. But I also find it interesting because of tweet's play around haza too which seems pretty awkward with the meta stuff and not wanting to elaborate, and then the random unvote after the vote count

 

[RDK]

For me I don’t really understand why he would express caution just like I said at the time lol. So he wants to be voted, and? I even asked him what possible role would mean we have to be cautious and he had nothing so it’s not even like he had something in mind lol, which means it’s probably just virtue signalling, kinda like how for some reason scum keep telling us to watch for the executioner and thinking that’s a good tactic

If you are choosing to ignore possible scum motivation behind wanting votes then sure...

I dont think its unreasonable for me to be apprehensive of that though especially when any such role would be unconventional already, why would it automatically be a town role?

I think Big Man was getting at the reasoning for that being why would scum want votes on them? This doesn't really compute with me because why would town?

I'm just not really getting what either of you are saying maybe

 

[RDK]

But the whole “I’ve got meta reasons for reading him scum but I’m not gonna elaborate in case he adapts” is no buys lmao

also if you’re actually town then that’s some pussy ass shit

The fact his response to me questioning him on it was to unvote me is a little unnerving.