Don't Call It a Comeback! Mafia '26 (Game Thread)

[Barry Poppins]

The problem with this theory is I'm questioning why you brought up Blaze not saying the coaching theory about booty in the first place and you're responding by saying the posts Blaze and Booty made after confirmed your suspicions.

I need to know why you had any suspicions about Blaze not calling out Booty for coaching as well...due to the things that happened before you made the post not after lol

It's not that I had suspicions, just something that pinged me as potentially important for later. I wanted to note it just to have it on record in case Blaze flips scum.

I think we're having confusion that Blaze not mentioning Booty is a big gotcha moment rather than an interesting side note that could be important later lol

 

[Chris]

It's not that I had suspicions, just something that pinged me as potentially important for later. I wanted to note it just to have it on record in case Blaze flips scum.

I think we're having confusion that Blaze not mentioning Booty is a big gotcha moment rather than an interesting side note that could be important later lol

No I kinda get that part of it. But I just don't get what made you think it's interesting. It's like you just think "blaze commented on one new player but not the other, sketchy" and I don't think that's good analysis when both new players are playing a lot differently. If they were playing similarly it would be a great point to lake

 

[Barry Poppins]

If Blaze is scum then I'm probably clearing Brett and booty and I would probably say Jean is the most likely candidate for partner bc I think having him as a partner would be the only way a scum blaze goes at Brett with a coaching theory

But blaze probs just town so that doesn't matter. Thoughts for if I'm wrong later tho I guess

I was actually about to post that I'm not sure if both Booty and Blaze are scum if they'd be bold enough to try that strategy btw lol, I think Booty might just be town lol.

 

[Professor Booty]

And Troop just a big mystery

 

[Barry Poppins]

No I kinda get that part of it. But I just don't get what made you think it's interesting. It's like you just think "blaze commented on one new player but not the other, sketchy" and I don't think that's good analysis when both new players are playing a lot differently. If they were playing similarly it would be a great point to lake

From what I've was reading, had Blaze really said anything on his thoughts about Booty? I know Booty hasn't been, for lack of a better term, analytical, but surely there's something to pick through in his posts. That's where I was pinged. I dunno, it was a spur of the moment comment I thought I'd bring up lol

 

[Professor Booty]

Are you shocked I’m not analytical?

 

[Barry Poppins]

Are you shocked I’m not analytical?

You need less feeling and more logic, mister. /s

 

[Chris]

From what I've was reading, had Blaze really said anything on his thoughts about Booty? I know Booty hasn't been, for lack of a better term, analytical, but surely there's something to pick through in his posts. That's where I was pinged. I dunno, it was a spur of the moment comment I thought I'd bring up lol

From what I can see he's only commented on Booty's suspicions of himself with some defenses. Booty has committed on him tho, I struggle to see scum blaze using booty as part of a plan here

 

[Professor Booty]

You need less feeling and more logic, mister. /s

Eventually

 

[Barry Poppins]

From what I can see he's only commented on Booty's suspicions of himself with some defenses. Booty has committed on him tho, I struggle to see scum blaze using booty as part of a plan here

Just a hypothetical question but what if Booty is co-scum with Blaze? Just asking.

 

[Chris]

Just a hypothetical question but what if Booty is co-scum with Blaze? Just asking.

How the fuck dare you not think there's only one scum is my answer to this

 

[Barry Poppins]

How the fuck dare you not think there's only one scum is my answer to this

 

[Chris]

But seriously why would that be plausible when Booty instantly said Blaze's coaching theory looked sketchy, it's not like he even waiting for anyone else to jump on it.

I'll say voting right after you on Blaze is a bit sketchier but I think that's again pretty natural for a new player, I was never good at figuring out the right or wrong time for a proper vote when I had suspicions bc I was always paranoid of Mafia jumping on my wrong read

 

[Chris]

Theres not 3 scum I think we can assume so if booty and blaze planned blaze making a post about Brett being coached that I disagreed with and booty instantly saying it looked fishy and coming off Brett a bit for Blaze....well hats off to them there

 

[Barry Poppins]

Theres not 3 scum I think we can assume so if booty and blaze planned blaze making a post about Brett being coached that I disagreed with and booty instantly saying it looked fishy and coming off Brett a bit for Blaze....well hats off to them there

Yeah lol which is why I don't think that is.

The hypothesis for scum Blaze trying to buddy town Booty could work theoretically if it just plain backfired and Booty just isn't going along with it haha