Don't Call It a Comeback! Mafia '26 (Game Thread)

[Professor Booty]

Yay we all lived

And Grim was town

So I’m thinking who piled up on him after Chris already suspected him and why didn’t they go for Blaze who had the first two votes

 

[Professor Booty]

And why didn’t Brett get his vote in on time? Was it some sort of weird ploy or just an uncharacteristic error?

 

[O-Blaze]

No one died during the night interesting. Very interesting.

 

[Professor Booty]

why didn’t you kill anyone Blaze?

 

[O-Blaze]

Because I can't do night kills, and I'm not scum either.

I have a good theory for why no one died however. But, I want to wait for others to get here, and then I'll share my thoughts.

 

[Professor Booty]

Why? It’s not like they can’t just read it later. Suspicious. You want to get immediate reactions so you can cater your lies?

 

[O-Blaze]

Nope. Not at all. I mean I can go ahead and say right now. But once I do, I write my death wish for the next night phase.

 

[Professor Booty]

OK, wait why would Sharing your theory now or later make a difference if you’re worried about being killed? That makes no sense. AlsoAnyone who kills someone that shares a theory about them the night after is a moron. That’s just a stupid move.

 

[Professor Booty]

My theory is that it was a Sky decision since we have so few players. But that could not be allowed I’m not sure

 

[O-Blaze]

OK, wait why would Sharing your theory now or later make a difference if you’re worried about being killed? That makes no sense. AlsoAnyone who kills someone that shares a theory about them the night after is a moron. That’s just a stupid move.

Because let me paint this picture, and you're right in away. But me calling it out might be what saves me.

But when D1 ended I figured one of the two strongest players would die.. by strongest I don't mean this exact game, I just meant mafia. That's Chris or Jeff. So I asked myself which was the most likely. So I picked Chris, and me having the doctor role means either 1. I made the right choice, and protected Chris, or 2. They didn't try killing anyone in the middle of the night.

But me being town, and being doctor who protects a player, then there has to be ways for scum to kill during the night. Now where it puts my life at risk, they know now I can protect a player at night, they might take me out tonight to stop it.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Good job. I'll be on around 1830/1900 est

 

[Professor Booty]

Because let me paint this picture, and you're right in away. But me calling it out might be what saves me.

But when D1 ended I figured one of the two strongest players would die.. by strongest I don't mean this exact game, I just meant mafia. That's Chris or Jeff. So I asked myself which was the most likely. So I picked Chris, and me having the doctor role means either 1. I made the right choice, and protected Chris, or 2. They didn't try killing anyone in the middle of the night.

But me being town, and being doctor who protects a player, then there has to be ways for scum to kill during the night. Now where it puts my life at risk, they know now I can protect a player at night, they might take me out tonight to stop it.

Well shit. I had no idea of the Doctor thing so this feels genuine or written up by your scum partner but I’m starting to move off you a bit

 

[O-Blaze]

Well shit. I had no idea of the Doctor thing so this feels genuine or written up by your scum partner but I’m starting to move off you a bit

Yeah like you see how I Grim's flip it had vanilla, or how in whatever message you got from Sky at the start would have you a role. Thankfully that is what I got. Anyway. I do got a post i wanna go back and answer i was asked when the no talking started

 

[O-Blaze]

I think even you would agree that as scum you'd be conscious of this and make sure to try and throw it into your play for believability though

So from that, I would say we shouldn't really use it as a tell for you at all, its how i imagine you'd play either way

I definitely would throw in how confident I'm not in myself, i can agree there. I wouldn't play much different, maybe slightly more cautious but not even that much. But yeah I know what people know about me and I would use it to my advantage for sure.

 

[Chris]

You didn't have to out yourself blaze bc yeah you're probably for sure getting offed tonight without anything we can do about it lol ask if you can self target

But yeah I assume they tried to kill me and I was hoping a doc would work it out too lol