A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Poyser]

Tbh, we could have piled on your Wang vote this morning without the vote steal if we'd all been online to do it quickly enough. You left a decent window there.

But you weren’t online before I unvoted lol, so not really true is it

 

[Tremendez]

Not like “cp was lynched for no reason” is it? He’s claimed PGO and somebody had claimed to visit him and is still alive…

It’s a discrepancy, sure, but over harder more concrete reads you had? No lie, under most circumstances I’d have been the same lynch one, one has to be lying, but I think this point in the game, someone I was reading before that is probably better and if we catch another scum, then we have wiggle room to figure the PGO.

I didn’t say no reason, btw, I said for reasons.

It’s no worries. We’ve all lost games in endgame. Honestly, scum got so lucky off Wang’s bus choice.

No idea why he picked the claimed PGO.

 

[RDK]

There was some absolutely WOAT town play so it's hardly surprising scum won. That Ekko stuff was just baffling

 

[Barry Poppins]

So who won.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Thanks for the game smark. Congratulations fellow scum compatriots and gg everyone!

 

[Tremendez]

Also you’re saying that scum didn’t need the vote steal because they could have lynched jonny without. That’s the point, the hated townie should have never been a thing in the first place. Vote steals are just lame as fuck in general

I didn’t invent it.

But you came right out and voted Wang right away so even without Jonny town lynched Wang, scum shoot that night and win.

Town myslynched three times and four with Wang. They win with or without those two roles. From the way the play went this game.

 

[Tremendez]

So who won.

Mafia.

 

[Comrade Khan]

So who won.

Us scumbois

Junk
Me
Blaze
4th
Chris

 

[Poyser]

I’m a bit annoyed I let TFW off so easily with what was such a shit claim all round when he claimed not to use his role after mass claim lol. That’s part of why I don’t think this pattern of play is something I can deal with, I just didn’t have the time and usually I’d have been all over that and grilling him. I should’ve just shot blaze when I wanted to shoot blaze. I thought I was being smart by waiting to see what TFW would do with his role which is why I opted for zinger. But then we got fucked by Wang not having a clue how to use his role lol.

also let’s take a minute to appreciate the fucking WOAT play by Ekko that completely derailed an entire day. Obviously I knew he didn’t have a positive on me, so I thought 100% he was scum that failed to kill me. No turns out it’s just idiot town thinking they’re being clever. That’s never not fucking infuriating.

the traitor is just whatever. Duel and execute shouldn’t have both been with scum. If junk isn’t a duelist she probably gets lynched on D2 lol

 

[Dolph Zinger]

I sussed Jeff and Chris super early, Noelle a bit after, Blaze escaped my notice until he got mech'd

 

[Comrade Khan]

And ya the ekko stuff was rough. There was a 10 min window where poyser could have been executed w a vote steal. Ekko gets lynched next day. Curtains

 

[Poyser]

I didn’t invent it.

But you came right out and voted Wang right away so even without Jonny town lynched Wang, scum shoot that night and win.

Town myslynched three times and four with Wang. They win with or without those two roles. From the way the play went this game.

None of town voted wang lol, I unvoted and said I wanted to think about it. It wasn’t a mislynch, it was a 100% mafia wagon…

 

[Chris]

So who won.

Me

And some other folks probably

 

[Comrade Khan]

Huge congratulations to @The Blaze on his first victory as mafia on his first attempt btw!

 

[Tremendez]

Junk was a survivor lover before she joined. That’s why she had the duelist shot. Something to claim.

On hindsight I probably won’t do that again, but was looking at her more as an Indy.

I have had duelist and an executioner actually start on a mafia team before though. Whether or not I do that depends JB how much killing power is against mafia, usually. But, yeah, something to consider.