Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Comrade Khan]

Well we now have a pseudo-cop outed so I think i'm within my right to question the choice

I dont buy this. Mchenry made no slips last game n u implied the choice overall was bad n sketchy lije i somehow should know hed reveal it? Nah, theres no basis for that before the fact. U tried to paint my choice as bad using something id have no way of anticipating. Furthermore u didnt react to the reveal or him at all in a natural way but just now are saying it after i asked u. Feels kind of forced my dude.

 

[John McHenry]

How would he know you had 3 names though?

He asked me if I heard music. I said Christmas carols I gave my clue that you must watch. 3 names I said must watch

 

[Lethal]

Active players list not being in the OP and not numbered is a little miffing tbh

@The Lich King small request for the list to be numbered and in your OP? Thank you.

I'm gonna wait for Jeff's reply to my answer and then see where I want to head.

I'm also intrigued as to Doddsy's case on mando and why he wants others to run with him. Ideally some receipts of the 'night and day' approach

 

[Lethal]

I dont buy this. Mchenry made no slips last game n u implied the choice overall was bad n sketchy lije i somehow should know hed reveal it? Nah, theres no basis for that before the fact. U tried to paint my choice as bad using something id have no way of anticipating. Furthermore u didnt react to the reveal or him at all in a natural way but just now are saying it after i asked u. Feels kind of forced my dude.

One could speculate that he's a little nervous about the role

 

[Comrade Khan]

I said I played irl 1 like 5 years ago this is my 2nd game in forum.

I believe you know this?

Could you be lying about being the caroler?

You knew I had 3 names, you begged for them I didn't give them up, and are now playing it like I was a super logical choice. If you'd said I was the best town read that'd make more sense

The point remains u know how to play . The role didnt say ud know 1 is scum explicitly, i got confirmation from juice to see if u werent being funny. It made it sound like ud just get names. Thats why i wanted them so bad (n at thjs point should be public)

And yes anyone can be lying about anything tgars indeed mafia

 

[RDK]

I dont buy this. Mchenry made no slips last game n u implied the choice overall was bad n sketchy lije i somehow should know hed reveal it? Nah, theres no basis for that before the fact. U tried to paint my choice as bad using something id have no way of anticipating. Furthermore u didnt react to the reveal or him at all in a natural way but just now are saying it after i asked u. Feels kind of forced my dude.

You're paranoid mate

I obviously think you're town with that role lol, im not trying to make you look bad

Just don't think you can be too upset about the outcome we have here

 

[Lethal]

He asked me if I heard music. I said Christmas carols I gave my clue that you must watch. 3 names I said must watch

Hmm okie then.

I'd love to know those 3 names ya know, could be good food for thought

 

[Comrade Khan]

Active players list not being in the OP and not numbered is a little miffing tbh

@The Lich King small request for the list to be numbered and in your OP? Thank you.

I'm gonna wait for Jeff's reply to my answer and then see where I want to head.

I'm also intrigued as to Doddsy's case on mando and why he wants others to run with him. Ideally some receipts of the 'night and day' approach

What u need?

 

[Lethal]

What u need?

Oh, I just answered why I vibed with Haza's question re: McHenry being your choice (I'd asked it just prior to him, but without the shade). I extended an offer of friendship.

 

[Just Juice]

added name to OP - sorry forget to move them from 3rd post.

 

[John McHenry]

Holt, sa, mando

 

[Comrade Khan]

Oh, I just answered why I vibed with Haza's question re: McHenry being your choice (I'd asked it just prior to him, but without the shade). I extended an offer of friendship.

oh ok ya, thats fine that u asked first, logical enough why ud like it

 

[Lethal]

added name to OP - sorry forget to move them from 3rd post.

Merci

 

[Doddsy]

Unless he tells us he got info, I don't see much of a reason to go for someone like Mando now of all times.

I'm not saying Doddsy is necessarily wrong about Mando either, I guess my point is, Poyser just spent a night phase making his opinions fairly clear and he died, so why would we pick now of all times to go "BUT MANDO THO"?

That's an odd take tbh. Why would what Poyser was saying really factor in to anything to that sort of degree? On to people or not he's a high priority target, you're greatly downplaying the highly likely chance that someone would have just shot him to remove him from the game.

Also FWIW I don't think Haza shoots Poyser night 1. I don't think Jeff does either tbh but less so than Haza. Nothing concrete in that just GUT, I feel like they don't like killing the main players early like I don't.

Active players list not being in the OP and not numbered is a little miffing tbh

@The Lich King small request for the list to be numbered and in your OP? Thank you.

I'm gonna wait for Jeff's reply to my answer and then see where I want to head.

I'm also intrigued as to Doddsy's case on mando and why he wants others to run with him. Ideally some receipts of the 'night and day' approach

You played last game didn't you? Take a look at Mando early, he was fairly on hunt and involved early, pushing people and wasn't afraid to sort of step on toes.

Compare that to this game, largely absent and uninvolved from the main topics. Seems much more meek in comparison.

It's honestly pretty easily a stronger argument than either Haza/ekko have against them at the moment

 

[Comrade Khan]

im kind of an an impasse as I do agree ekko/haza s/s has some merit for not being a likely thing. im kind of waiting on something to happen too