New York. New Rules. Scream VI Mafia Game Thread

[Wang Chung]

If you read back on Lethal's posts, he's more Investigative and open on his thoughts, and to be fair, it's not like I really disagreed with many of his thoughts.

I may look back on his posts once I get home, but gut feeling tells me this is a focused town Lethal.

I will go back and read them again.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

 

[Barry Poppins]

Sully makes a compelling case here and I'm already inclined to vote for OMB, so let's do this.

Unvote: Man
Vote: OMB

 

[Sully]

@Sully If you go back and look I said more that if your mafia that on d1 your post should be looked at more than anything and shit. FWIW I think at least that is how you play lol. I certainly even still don't think you be my first lynch option.

Ok yes, but you listed four names you thought were scum and only one of those had ANY actual reasoning. If you worded it more as "these are some people to be wary of based on past game experiences" then sure.

But you have to actually connect that to posts from THIS game for it to work.

@Bobby Barrows I just found his post odd seem like some fluff and it seem like he wasn't playing town game his last post def didn't come off townie.

Man has way more posts than you and I, and I went through them and a lot of them are actually asking questions and making reads. Can you quote which post you saw as fluff and why it concerns you?

And also in his last post, you said he didn't come off as a townie, what specifically in that post gave you that read (other than disagreeing with you)?

Genuinely, if you can convince, I'll vote for Man. But you HAVE to actually give some damn reasons man.

 

[Just Juice]

i can conceive a world where Wang is Town and Grim and Sully are both maf sided with a town lynch order list of: Mando, Juice, Omb & Sky for the game win

 

[Wang Chung]

View attachment 69691

@Sully If you go back and look I said more that if your mafia that on d1 your post should be looked at more than anything and shit. FWIW I think at least that is how you play lol. I certainly even still don't think you be my first lynch option.

@Bobby Barrows I just found his post odd seem like some fluff and it seem like he wasn't playing town game his last post def didn't come off townie.

Are you saying you that he was just posting to post at that moment even though if I recall he was talking to Sky at that time about something and some about juice.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

 

[Barry Poppins]

Ok yes, but you listed four names you thought were scum and only one of those had ANY actual reasoning. If you worded it more as "these are some people to be wary of based on past game experiences" then sure.

But you have to actually connect that to posts from THIS game for it to work.



Man has way more posts than you and I, and I went through them and a lot of them are actually asking questions and making reads. Can you quote which post you saw as fluff and why it concerns you?

And also in his last post, you said he didn't come off as a townie, what specifically in that post gave you that read (other than disagreeing with you)?

Genuinely, if you can convince, I'll vote for Man. But you HAVE to actually give some damn reasons man.

I would answer part of this but I'd rather have OMB answer in his own defense.

 

[Sully]

I would answer part of this but I'd rather have OMB answer in his own defense.

We'll see if he does. If he ignores it, then feel free to answer it because I do want to know. I'm going to go back and reread it again myself.

 

[Barry Poppins]

We'll see if he does. If he ignores it, then feel free to answer it because I do want to know. I'm going to go back and reread it again myself.

SS arguably makes the best case for it if you're looking for another person's reasoning but again, I would suggest weighing that with OMB's reasoning only after he answers it.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Alright. Pretty close to time for me to call it a night. While not my first choice, I like the case that’s been made. Feels like a solid shot here Vote: OMB

 

[Colt Magnum]

It's not really a one vs the other to me at this point. I don't have enough to get an actual read on Man, and OMB flipping scum wouldn't clear him by any means.

If Man flips scum, I would definitely back off OMB for a bit though.

Man flipping town would make OMB look really bad for sure, but we already know he's going off essentially nothing for his scum reads to begin with.

OMB flipping town would probably make me look worse than Man at this point. I think Man is sussing OMB for the same reasons I am, and it's the fact that he's calling us scum without any actual basis. See when I called Sky out for being defensive, it was in response to my posts where I actually was giving reasons and asking questions. OMB isn't asking questions and his entire scum read list was all just shit about us as players and nothing about the game. I don't think he even read any of our game posts when he made it.

And couldn't really that same be said bout anyone on d1? If I remember so too least on WS I seen people all the time base stuff off previous games? And I mean in actuality couldn't this also be case of pot calling kettle black with you twisting your own narrative as well I mean thats sort of the game in a nutshell. I'm not panicked by any means and you can certainly try and dissect my post enough to fit whatever mold does seem rather interesting that two or three have jumped onto me as scum discussion rather quick. I'm off to bed tho or at least trying to just took some pain meds to help with my hyper extended knee.

 

[Just Juice]

what are these bad tells exactly? Just sounds like you are taking a position of belief, but can remove it at and time and scum read him which comes off like a setup for later in the game.

called it

 

[Barry Poppins]

That did not help assuage my thoughts on OMB atm, my man just pulled a "no u" and dipped

 

[Just Juice]

sometimes - you just know exactly what someone is going to do. also this wagon on OMB, is literally a CFD. called it twice

 

[Barry Poppins]

sometimes - you just know exactly what someone is going to do. also this wagon on OMB, is literally a CFD. called it twice

Stop using that terminology please, respectfully.

 

[Just Juice]

there is only one name for it in mafia - and the acronym is CFD.